The building at 70 Sunset Avenue covers 29,118 square feet and was the largest grocery store in the Village of Westhampton Beach. Its Lidl stayed open through Sunday, October 11, 2026. A Lidl US spokesperson told Patch that every employee at the store would be offered a position at another Lidl location.
With the store closed, a full-size cart run now means a drive out of the village. Until a new supermarket opens on Sunset Avenue, the weekly shop splits across a handful of specialty counters within a few blocks of each other and a Saturday market that changes address on November 28. This has happened at this address before, and the stretch between grocers has never been a quick one.
The Sunset Avenue Store Has Closed Three Times Since 2015
Lidl was the most recent of several grocers at 70 Sunset Avenue. Reporting from 27east and Newsday traces the sequence:
- Waldbaum's operated the store for many years and closed in September 2015. Its parent company, the Great Atlantic & Pacific Tea Co., better known as A&P, had filed for bankruptcy protection that July.
- Best Market bought the store in bankruptcy court for $4 million and opened in 2016.
- Lidl US bought Best Market's stores, including the Westhampton Beach location, in a deal Newsday says was finalized in January 2019. The Westhampton Beach Best Market closed in November 2020.
- Lidl reopened the space in May 2021 and ran it for about five and a half years.
The last transition left a gap. Best Market closed in November 2020 and Lidl opened the following May, about six months later. Patch recalled that shoppers were upset to find themselves without a supermarket at the time, and that it was months before Lidl opened.
Village officials have described the same problem each time. Mayor Ralph Urban told 27east that many residents liked Lidl's produce, bakery and prices. He also pointed to how hard it is to run a supermarket in a village with a busy summer and a quiet off-season. Cary Staller, president of Staller Associates Realty, which represents the landlord, said Lidl's lease expired in March and the grocer got an extension. He told Newsday that Lidl seemed to feel the area was "sort of this upscale vacation market and it didn't fit in with their prototype."
What Is Known About the Next Grocer
The landlord says a full-service supermarket has been secured for the space. Staller told Newsday he would not name the incoming tenant because of a confidentiality agreement. No opening date has been announced.
The space has drawn plenty of speculation. According to Patch, Trader Joe's said it has no confirmed location in Westhampton Beach. When asked about online claims that a Holiday Farms would open there, a Holiday Farms representative would "neither confirm nor deny" the rumor. Patch also reported, citing 27east, that a fake newspaper article with a doctored Trader Joe's sign had circulated on social media.
For now, a supermarket is confirmed but the name and opening date are not. Based on the last turnover, the village's food shopping will run on its smaller shops for at least the coming weeks.
Small Shops in the Village Will Carry Most of the Weekly Shop
Newsday counts "a few delis and small food markets" in Westhampton Beach. One difference from 2020 is that Citarella opened on Montauk Highway in the spring of 2026. Southforker reported its opening on April 30, while Newsday puts it in May. These shops cover most of what a Lidl trip used to:
| Shop | Address | What it covers | Posted hours |
|---|---|---|---|
| Citarella | 141 Montauk Hwy | Produce, cheese, meat, seafood, prepared foods | Daily, 7 a.m. to 7:30 p.m. |
| Justin's Chop Shop | 71 Sunset Ave. | Prime meats, fresh fish, sandwiches, prepared foods, pantry goods | Check with the shop |
| Mill Road Seafood | 212 Mill Road | Fresh seafood | Wed to Fri 10:30 a.m. to 5:30 p.m.; Sat 10 a.m. to 5:30 p.m.; Sun 10 a.m. to 4 p.m.; closed Mon and Tue |
| Beach Bakery | 112 Main Street | Baked goods and cakes | Daily, opening at 6 a.m. |
| Haskell's Seafood Market and Café | Main Street | Take-home fresh seafood, prepared seafood | Check with the shop |
Citarella is closest to a one-stop shop. When it opened, owner Joe Gurrera told Southforker that customers in Westhampton Beach had asked for years for a Citarella closer to home. Its Hamptons page lists personal-shopping help for weekly groceries, plus Hamptons delivery and curbside pickup. Citarella's current posted hours are shorter than the 6 a.m. to 8 p.m. schedule reported at its opening. Check the store page before an early or late trip.
Justin's Chop Shop is on Sunset Avenue, the same street as the empty supermarket. Southforker describes it as an independently owned neighborhood shop that sells pantry goods along with its meat counter.
Mill Road Seafood's schedule needs the most planning. It is closed Monday and Tuesday and closes at 4 p.m. on Sunday, so fish for the start of the week means buying on the weekend.
Saturday Morning Matters More, and It Moves on November 28
The village's farm-fresh produce comes on Saturdays, and its location depends on the date.
- Through November 21: The outdoor Westhampton Beach Farmers Market runs Saturdays from 9 a.m. to 1 p.m. on the Village Green. November 21 is the last outdoor date listed for 2026.
- November 28 through December 26: The Greater Westhampton Chamber of Commerce runs its Holiday & Winter Market on Saturdays from 9 a.m. to 2 p.m. at St. Mark's Episcopal Church, 40 Main Street. Vendors sell handmade goods, clothing, jewelry, specialty foods and baked items.
- Through April 24, 2027: The winter farmers market inside the Holiday & Winter Market continues on Saturdays through April 24, 2027.
The first indoor market and the village's Tree & Menorah Lighting fall on the same day, November 28. The lighting runs from 5:30 to 6:30 p.m. on the Village Green, with Santa and a parade of lights by the Westhampton Beach Fire Department. On that Saturday you can shop the market at St. Mark's in the morning and walk to the Green for the lighting in the evening, both on Main Street.
The Chamber's Holiday & Winter Markets listing runs until the last weekend of April 2027. That covers the whole off-season, however long the new grocer takes to open.
The Nearest Full-Size Supermarket Is in Hampton Bays
Staples and bulk paper goods are hard to cover at specialty counters. Stop & Shop's store locator lists its Hampton Bays supermarket at 194 West Montauk Highway, open from 6 a.m. to 10 p.m. every day. It also lists stores at 167 Main Street in Southampton and 1615 Old Country Road in Riverhead.
The Hampton Bays store opens an hour before Citarella and closes two and a half hours later, so it works for a staples run before or after a workday. Many households will likely split the week. A big staples run happens in Hampton Bays, and the rest comes from shops in the village.
These pieces add up to a workable weekly routine:
- Weekend: The Saturday market on the Village Green, which moves to St. Mark's from November 28. Fish from Mill Road Seafood before its Sunday 4 p.m. close.
- Monday and Tuesday: Citarella, Justin's Chop Shop and Beach Bakery, since Mill Road Seafood is closed.
- Once a week: A trip to Stop & Shop in Hampton Bays for staples.
- When the drive doesn't fit: Citarella delivery or curbside pickup.
The empty building at 70 Sunset Avenue now has a new tenant lined up but no name or opening date. Waldbaum's closed in September 2015 and Best Market in November 2020. With Lidl's closing in October 2026, the store has now gone dark three times, and this gap starts later in the fall than the one in 2020. It also starts with Citarella on Montauk Highway, which wasn't open six months ago.
If you'd like to talk about what's happening in Westhampton Beach, from Sunset Avenue to the Village Green, Rachel York is a call away. Schedule a Free Consultation.