"Dude, this bridge is fascinating," an MTA flagman told The East Hampton Star in late October, standing on the closed span over the Long Island Rail Road tracks in Amagansett. "It's a cool old bridge. I've never seen a wood-timber bridge, with, like, pavement over it, on Long Island."
The bridge was built in 1895 and has been closed to all traffic since July 2023. Demolition of its 131-foot span is expected this winter. The replacement won't carry traffic until spring 2028, and the reason has as much to do with the railroad under the bridge as with the road over it. The new span is being designed for a busier Montauk Branch, so the timeline for getting to Lazy Point is now tied to the timeline for East End rail service.
A five-ton bridge on a road that kept getting heavier
The old span was rated for five tons, or 10,000 pounds. Stephen Lynch, East Hampton Town's highway superintendent, told the Star that drivers ignoring that limit wore it down. "Cement trucks went over. Dump trucks. Two years ago, a modular home crossed this span," he said. Cracks in the asphalt deck now line up with the wooden planks underneath.
The bridge was declared structurally deficient and closed in July 2023. The MTA included it in a three-bridge package with Sagg Road in Sagaponack and River Avenue in Eastport. The River Avenue bridge has been closed since early 2024. The design-build contract went to RCC/GCCOM A Joint Venture LLC, a pairing of Railroad Construction Company, Inc. and GCCOM Construction Company, Inc. The contract is worth $36,589,000 and runs 721 calendar days. It covers demolition and replacement of all three bridges, plus approach roadwork and a drainage system at each site.
The routes that have stood in since July 2023
The bridge is the direct link over the tracks to Promised Land and the Lazy Point area. At an Amagansett Citizens Advisory Committee meeting covered by the Star in July 2025, the people described as most affected were residents of Devon, Lazy Point and parts of Napeague.
Local reporting describes the routes drivers have used since the closure:
- Abram's Landing Road. The MTA's designated motorist detour, still in effect as of late October 2026.
- Napeague Meadow Road. The Star's 2023 closure report named it as the other way for motorists, cyclists and pedestrians to reach Cranberry Hole Road and Lazy Point.
- Bendigo Road or Cross Highway. 27east reported residents heading north on one of these, then taking Abrahams Landing Road to Montauk Highway.
The longer drive also matters for emergencies. In January 2025, Supervisor Kathee Burke-Gonzalez told the Town Board that the prolonged closure had disrupted local traffic and daily commutes and slowed emergency access. The Star noted that Cranberry Hole Road was Amagansett's most direct route to part of Napeague State Park, where fire departments responding to a brush fire would have to go the long way around.
What this winter looks like on Cranberry Hole Road
Crews arrived in late October. Asplundh contractors were trimming limbs near the electrical wires while the MTA staged work on the span. Clearing was set to start the first week of November. Here is what to expect in the coming months:
- Work hours: weekdays, 7 a.m. to 3:30 p.m. Overnight or weekend work may be scheduled if needed, and the MTA has pledged to notify the town first.
- Neighbor notice: property owners near the bridge will receive a letter when work begins.
- Demolition: expected this winter. Councilman David Lys said it could come as early as December.
- Town Board briefing: MTA representatives are scheduled to present the replacement project to the East Hampton Town Board in December.
The December Town Board presentation will be the first public look at the schedule once demolition is underway.
The road from demolition to spring 2028
The span comes down in a few months. Rebuilding takes the rest of 2027. The Star laid out the sequence, and the MTA has said the schedule is subject to change.
| Phase | Expected timing | What happens |
|---|---|---|
| Demolition | Winter 2026–27 | The 131-foot timber-and-asphalt span is removed |
| Abutments | Summer 2027 | New abutments replace the 130-year-old timber supports |
| New span | Fall 2027 | A crane sets the concrete span in place |
| Approaches | Through completion | Milling, paving, curbs, sidewalks, new drainage and leaching basins |
| Traffic | March 2028 | Cranberry Hole Road reopens over the tracks |
The MTA's own target for the whole three-bridge package, including Sagg Road and River Avenue, is July 2028. Design was expected to be finished in January 2027.
The new bridge is sized for the trains underneath
The difference between the two bridges is mostly about load and width:
- Capacity: 80,000 pounds, up from 10,000
- Roadway width: 32 feet, up from about 21, with room for pedestrians and ADA access
- Fire apparatus: Assemblyman Tommy John Schiavoni told the advisory committee that fire trucks will be able to cross
Lys also pointed to the tracks below. "There's going to be two tracks underneath it here," Lys told the Star. "With more sidings and track space, more trains can be run. That's one of the best things about this project; it's being designed for the future."
That ties the bridge to the MTA's Amagansett Track Siding Extension. The Montauk Branch currently runs 27 miles on a single track between Southampton and Montauk, which limits how many trains can operate. The MTA plans to lengthen the Amagansett siding by 14 train-car lengths. That would leave 11 miles of single track between Amagansett and Montauk and 16 miles between Southampton and Amagansett. The siding work is scheduled to begin in the first quarter of 2028 and finish in the second quarter of 2029. Once it is done, the LIRR has said it will look to increase or improve Montauk Branch service. The Amagansett siding and the Hampton Bays station improvements together are estimated at $78 million from the 2025–29 Capital Plan.
On the current schedules, the siding work starts in the same quarter that Cranberry Hole Road is projected to reopen.
Ridership is the reason for the expansion. The MTA reported 1,212,229 Montauk Branch passengers as of late August 2026, against 1,138,921 at the same point in 2025, a 6.4 percent increase. Southampton station traffic was up 46 percent over the same window, and peak-summer East End trains often run close to full. The MTA also announced that the 5:13 p.m. train from Penn Station to Montauk, previously a summer-only run east of Speonk, would run year-round starting September 2026. Year-round riders already use the line. Watching the morning train pass from under the bridge, Lys told the Star that the commuter run carries a couple hundred people every day, many of them connected to area school districts. The South Fork Commuter Connection runs weekday train-and-shuttle service between Speonk and Montauk.
Similar work is underway farther west. In early April 2026 the LIRR began extending the Southampton station siding by about 80 feet so longer trains can use it, including trains serving New York City and the South Fork Commuter Connection. The Cranberry Hole Road bridge is the part of this rail program that Amagansett will drive over. Until March 2028, the way to Lazy Point is still Abram's Landing Road.
If you own a home in Devon, Lazy Point or Napeague, or you're weighing a purchase near Cranberry Hole Road, the bridge timeline affects how you'll get around for the next two years. Rachel York follows East End projects like this one closely and is happy to talk through what the schedule means for your property. Visit the Amagansett neighborhood page, or Schedule a Free Consultation and we'll get back to you promptly.